Loading

open print book held by a reader with colorful orange and red pillows supporting the book
Photo by Clay Banks on Unsplash

As a reader, I never considered that anyone but an editor had seen the book before it was released. Once I became an author, I realized that by the time a book reaches the bookshelves, many eyes have seen it. These first readers make a huge difference in how authors shape their story.

After listening to a podcast by Mary Adkins (The First Draft Club) about reader feedback, I got to thinking about my experiences with prepublication readers and those shared with me from my author friends.

Types of First Readers

Who are these first readers and when do they enter the picture? First readers—or prepublication readers—help shape the story, often before a professional editor gets involved. They come into the process at different stages, and each plays a different role in helping the author forge the story.

Critique Partners

While most first readers are bibliophiles who read regularly in the book’s genre, critique partners are other writers who exchange their early work with each other and give feedback on whether it’s working. They see the earliest rough version of the story, often referred to by authors as the messy first draft (for reasons). Critique partners help the author determine the story’s viability and offer feedback on things like character development, pacing, and plot.

Alpha Readers

Alpha readers also see an early draft and give feedback on plot points and story arc, similar to the work critique partners do, but from a reader’s point of view. They often brainstorm with the writer on what’s working and what’s not, discuss story direction, or point out areas that need more substance.

Beta Readers

Beta readers read the story after at least one editing pass and are the writer’s test readers from their target audience. Readers at this point are looking for issues with flow or pacing and any places where they don’t understand or lose interest in what’s happening.

Sensitivity Readers

Sensitivity readers are special readers who review the book specifically for cultural inaccuracies, representation issues, bias, stereotypes, or problematic language. They also may be experts in a certain subject and help the author with the language or knowledge around their expertise.

A fellow author once asked me to review her book featuring a character with epilepsy to make sure she got everything right. I really enjoyed that. (And she did great! Check out Play Me False by E.R. Whyte, if you’re interested.)

ARC Readers

ARC (Advanced Reader Copy) readers get a free copy of the finished book shortly before it’s published, often in exchange for a review when the book is released. At this point, the book is finished, so no further editing is needed and ARC readers don’t provide feedback (unless they’ve spotted a pesky typo that made it through ten rounds of editing!), just a review on their platform of choice.

Reader Feedback Essentials

Now that we’ve covered the types of first readers, you might be asking what kind of feedback should early readers give the author. I highly recommend listening to Mary’s 10-minute podcast episode. It gives excellent advice on feedback that truly helps writers. You can find the full episode on her website or YouTube channel.

Below are the main takeaways. If you ever find yourself doing a prepublication read, these are worth keeping in mind.

Where Did You Have That Thought?

Tell the writer exactly where in the text a thought or feeling occurred. List the chapter, page, scene, paragraph, etc. where it popped into your head. The best thing you can do for a writer is to call out the specific moment an impression rose in your mind.

A great example Mary gives is getting vague feedback like “I found this character to be unrealistic.” This leaves the author unsure of how to proceed or even where to start. But if you tell her “on this page when she says this, that doesn’t feel like something that character would say and she has similar reactions on these pages,” now the author has something concrete to work with.

(She gives several more examples in the podcast, which clarify how specific feedback helps authors.)

It’s a little more work for a reader, but the payoff for writers is invaluable. And may earn you a mention in the back of the book.

Capturing Your Thoughts

Depending on how you consume books (print books, ebooks, audiobooks), the process for taking notes like this differs. Here are some suggestions:

  1. Add comments directly in the manuscript using the track changes feature. I have an author friend who sends documents to her beta readers with track changes turned on. This way they can add comments directly into the manuscript. She then collates them so she can evaluate where different readers pegged the same issue. Both Word and Google Docs have this feature.
  2. Capture your thoughts on old-fashioned pen and paper. Jot your notes down, then scan them and send them. I have another friend who does this, and it’s very effective.
  3. Making notations in your e-reader. Many e-readers (e.g., Kindle, Apple Books, and Libby) have the capacity for making notations within the story, then reviewing your notes separately. Kindle has an export feature for your notes. And there’s always screenshots if your e-reader doesn’t allow exports.
  4. Create a spreadsheet to jot your notes. I have another friend who creates a spreadsheet and captures the page number, paragraph, what’s happening in the scene, and her thoughts about what she’s reading.
  5. Record voice memos. Some readers find it easier to talk through their reactions. This works too. Just send your recording or a transcript of it to the author.
open print book with notepad and pen ready to take notes
Photo by Debby Hudson on Unsplash
hand holding an ereader with lines highlighted; background image is a desk with a computer monitor and a plant
Photo by Baláz Kétyi on Unsplash

And as Mary points out, the format you use doesn’t matter because it means the world to the writer to receive specific feedback they can work with and don’t have to translate or try to read your mind. So use a method that works for you.

Don’t forget to capture the thought when it occurs. If you wait until the end of the chapter or scene, you may forget it. (My easily distracted brain totally does this.)

Wrap-Up

So, the next time you pick up a new book, know that it likely passed through many hands before it reached yours. Readers like you gave their time and support to help make it the best version it could be. And if you’re curious about becoming a beta reader, an ARC reader, or just want to better understand the journey a book takes before it hits the shelves, the best place to start is with the authors you already love. Follow them on social media, sign up for their newsletters, and let them know you’re interested. You might be surprised how warmly they respond.

Your Turn

For those who have done a prepublication read, I’d love to hear your favorite ways to make notes for the author. Please share your recommendations in the comments below.


Happy Reading!


NOTE: The email address field in the comment section is NOT required. Feel free to leave it blank. And if you do share your email, it will not be displayed or shared, nor are you subscribing to any list. Thank you!

Leave a Reply