Loading

A woman proofreading a composition
Photo by Ron Lach

How do you find a good editor? How do you know when the editor you’ve found is going to click with your story? And what do you do if you mismatch?

Writing the book is hard enough, but then you have to find editors who help you shape and polish it into the best version it can be. (At least I do. Hats off to those authors who don’t use professional editors.)

The First Time

I wrote and published my first book, Left Turn, in a vacuum. I researched and studied and learned all the things on my own. If you’ve followed my blog, you’ve seen that journey documented along the way.

When it came time to have that first book edited, I used Reedsy Marketplace to find both my developmental and line/copy editor. (Check out this article for a quick definition of the different types of editing.) Reedsy made it easy to shop for editors. I filled out a form telling them about my book (genre, length, synopsis, etc.) and about myself. Then they supplied a list of editors that matched, complete with their bios, ratings, and any reviews or recommendations from other authors. All communication with the editors, including quotes, payments, and followup, occur within Reedsy’s insulated platform.

This process worked great for me and was extremely efficient. I found both my dev editor and my line/copy editor on Reedsy. And once published, Left Turn won an award and has a 4.3 star rating with reviews from multiple countries, which reinforced the idea that my editors did a good job. Overall, I was pretty happy with the process.

But then, I started meeting and talking to other authors, who raved about their relationships with their editors. When they talked about how they met regularly and how the professional relationship had evolved into deep friendship, I couldn’t help but think, “I want that too!”

And, while I was happy with the editors I’d used on my first book, I wanted a deeper relationship with someone with my next book. I wanted something less… transactional. Something more personal.

Search for New Editors

While some editors can do all the editing passes, I like getting multiple eyes looking over my work. The more people who see it, the more mistakes we’ll catch. At least that’s the idea. Anyway, I set out to find a new developmental editor and a copy/line editor. 

First, I reached out to my contacts from the publishing world for recommendations. Then I took to social media to ask for recommendations. Fellow authors also suggested I scour the acknowledgements sections from books I enjoyed reading since authors often thank their editors in the book’s back matter.

After compiling a list of potential dev and copy editors, I did my research. I went to their sites, read their processes, and compared their prices.

Let me tell you something, the price of editing has increased significantly since 2022, when I published my first book. I had a bit of sticker shock. After I got over that, I narrowed down the field to a couple of folks who sounded like they were a good match. 

The second shock I got was how far out they were booked. I was expecting a couple of months, but some of these folks were booked out six and eight months. So, be forewarned, indie authors! You’ve got to get on their calendars EARLY.

Mismatch

What happens when you mismatch with an editor? Boy, this was a huge lesson learned for me. And a painful one.

The dev editor I went with for Code Block was friendly, excited about my story, and seemingly on the same page as me during our “get to know you” video call. It felt like a good match and I was excited to work with her. While she had my manuscript, she emailed me weekly with upbeat comments on what she was loving about the book. It came as a complete shock when I got the edits back and she wanted me to cut two-thirds of the story and focus more on the romance scenes between the two main characters. 

I think I walked around in shock for a full week, wondering if I had completely lost the plot as a writer. And while my head knew it was simply a poor match—that she was looking for a different story than I had written—my heart was suffering a massive blow.

Realizations

The biggest realization I came to was my books were definitely NOT straight romance, which was what she was trying to shape it into. They are stories about career women (and those they love) struggling to find their place in the world, both at work and in their personal lives. My books (written and in progress) have three distinct plot lines: her career, his career, and their romance. Some have an additional plot line involving a family member. The romance is not front and center.

word cloud of book genres

That might not sound like a big shift, but it is. It changes how you market the book, what audience you target, and how you tell people about your book. So, yeah… some deep thinking and reframing of my author goals came after this realization.

And my emotions were all over the board. Disappointment, anger, self-doubt. But mostly anger. I had paid a lot of money for this service. And not only money, but time. My manuscript was with her for six weeks. To get another developmental editor lined up to replace her was going to set back my publication date by months and I would still need to pay someone else. 

Once I got my emotions under control, I reached out to my author friends and talked about it. Surprisingly, several of them had gone through similar experiences, where they thought they had a good match, then were devastated by the results. I was not alone.

Next Steps

Once I started talking about it to my friends in the indie publishing world, I received a few offers to help and found another dev editor who’d had a cancellation and could fit me in. While it was still a setback time wise (and budget wise), I was looking at weeks, rather than months. (Thank goodness!) I also let my copyeditor know about the delay, which (thankfully!) she was able to accommodate.

While I waited for my new dev editor’s start date, I went through the edit suggestions from the original editor. I ignored all the input for slashing storylines and unearthed any helpful comments that would make my existing story better. It was a painful slog, but I got through it. Overall, I used about one-third of the comments she gave me.

Lessons Learned

After going through this experience, I want to share the lessons I learned, including advice from authors and editors who’ve experienced something similar.

  1. Know your book’s genre. Even if it’s a mash up, you should be able to articulate it. Many editors specialize in one or two genres. If your book is a thriller, you don’t want someone who primarily edits romance.
  2. Always get a sample edit. (From an editor: If they won’t do a sample edit, move on.) While it’s not a guaranteed catch all, you should be able weed out any obvious mismatches from the feedback they give you on those first few pages.
  3. Discuss the themes and goals of your book in the initial call. Make sure you are clear about what your book is and is not. (The key questions I missed: Are you writing a romance? Or is your book a different genre with a romantic element?)
  4. Ask how they maintain the author’s vision or voice. When the editor imposes their own vision on the author’s work, everyone loses.
  5. Do not depend on “friend of a friend” recommendations. The chemistry between each author, editor, and book differs. What worked for one doesn’t always work for another.
  6. The author/editor community is a wonderful, uplifting place. I received so much warm, positive support when I shared this experience with my publishing friends. Their encouragement and immediate move to help was comforting while I went through what felt like a major setback.

And a suggestion for editors: When you come across a book that isn’t what you expected, stop and do a check-in with the author. Just resetting expectations could save a lot of heartache (and potential revenue loss). 

As a professional business consultant, whenever I walk into a client’s site and find the job isn’t what was originally conveyed, I immediately revisit the scope of the project with the client and make sure we’re on the same page before proceeding with any work. I expect professional editors to do the same.

Other Resources

While writing this, I searched for articles that also gave advice on finding the right fit for an editor. Most of them gave the same generic questions to ask, but here are two that went deeper:

How to Find a Book Editor You Can Trust by Blake Atwood from The Write Life.

Twelve Questions to Ask to Find the Right Book Editor or Writing Coach by Sarah Welch from Inkdrop Lit. (This one was really good and got into maintaining the author’s vision.)

Wrap-Up

The good news is that if you find yourself in this situation, you can recover. All feedback is worth something, even if it’s what NOT to do.

Don’t let it stop you cold. Just like with readers, not every editor is a match for your book. Eventually, you’ll find someone who gets your story and what you’re sharing with the world.

And if you don’t have any author friends yet, go find some. You can connect through social media, but the best connections I’ve made have been at writer’s conferences (virtual or in person). Once you begin building your posse, you’ll be amazed at how supportive they are and how fast those connections grow.

Your Turn

I’d love to hear about your experiences with finding an editor (both good and bad). Please share any tips or lessons learned that you have for other authors down in the comments below. 


In the meantime, happy writing!


NOTE: The email address field in the comment section is NOT required. Feel free to leave it blank. And if you do share your email, it will not be displayed or shared, nor are you subscribing to any list. Thank you!

Leave a Reply